8 allege they were suckered by real estate ring

Plaintiffs say they paid about $310,000 for their condos, and their market value today is no more than $50,000

By Jamie Ross

Courthouse News Service

Eight people claim in court that they were suckered for “hundreds of thousand dollars” in real estate seminars and “millions of dollars” in condos that a ring sold them for four times the “true value of each property.”

Eight “unsophisticated and unsuspecting ‘student’ investors” claim that James Smith and the Smith Success Group’s real estate seminars induced them to trust Darel Snyder and Brycen Snyder, who in turn induced them to buy condos, allegedly for 20 percent below market value, though actually at 400 percent to 450 percent above market.

    Lead plaintiffs Jan and Bonnie Aitken sued a long list of defendants in Maricopa County Court.

Lead defendant James Smith is a resident of Utah, Florida and Arizona, and the Snyders live in Arizona, according to the complaint.

The plaintiffs claim that Smith and the Smith Success Group “used, to their advantage, the high degree of trust and confidence they created during the ‘educational’ process to manipulate their students to meet with and trust” the Snyders.

Smith and the Snyders bought condos at a price “exponentially higher than the true market value” through a “fraudulent real estate appraisal” which defendant Eldon Drue Bates, a licensed Arizona real estate appraiser prepared, “and which set the appraised value, or simply creating fraudulent deeds of trust, the substance of which identified a purchase price that was the substantially higher than market value,” the complaint states.

After the plaintiffs agreed to buy one or more condos, they say, “the Snyder defendants required each plaintiff to utilize the services of [defendant] 1st Metropolitan – a company which held itself out as a real estate mortgage broker, to obtain numerous ‘Alt-A’ loan products from said defendants’ then ‘preferred lender,’ – i.e., one or more of the bank defendants … [that] would only make these ‘special loans’ to the Smith defendants’ students.”

The plaintiffs claim that Bates did appraisals that were “submitted to the bank defendants so as not to create a ‘red flag’ during the underwriting and approval process – hence, these appraisals were never even considered because each and every one of the plaintiffs’ loan applications were guaranteed to be approved, by one particular ‘senior underwriter,’ who was independently contracted by the bank defendants, and at the same time paid by Smith defendants and Snyder defendants to illegally approve each of these loan applications.”

After the plaintiffs bought their condos, Smith or the Snyders “unloaded” their condos “for a price which caused the real estate ‘comps’ to drastically decrease in value,” the complaint states.

The plaintiffs claim that “one or more individuals who were secretly affiliated with Smith defendants and/or the Snyder defendants contacted several Smith Success Group students and offered to assist them with ‘short selling’ their particular condominium unit. Plaintiffs recently discovered that those who opted to ‘short sell,’ ended up ‘short selling’ their unit to another Smith Success Group student, on terms and conditions which were respectively identical to their – albeit at a price which was once again artificially set.”

The plaintiffs say they paid about $310,000 for their condos, whose market value today is no more than $50,000.

They seek special, general, and punitive damages for racketeering, fraud, and negligent misrepresentation, and a temporary restraining order to stop the defendants from “taking any action to sale, transfer, [or] foreclose” on their properties for non-payment.

Here are the defendants: James Smith; Darel Snyder; Brycen Snyder; David Dewar; Kenneth Losch; Eldon Drue Bates; National Real Estate Investors; National Training Institute; Real Estate Investor Support; Net Marketing Alliance; Legal Protection Group; Net Marketing Alliance; The Coaching Club; Creating Wealth Summit; Property Solutions and Information Group dba PSI Group; Garden Village Associates at Grayhawk; UH Condominium Corporation; Bates & Associates; Empire Equity Inc. dba 1st Metropolitan Mortgage, and affiliates; Greenpoint Mortgage Funding; Countrywide Financial Corporation; Countrywide Home Loans; Bank of America; and GMAC Mortgage.

The plaintiffs are represented by Joel Thompson.


Arizona sues 2 mortgage relief companies/East Valley Tribune

Share this!

Additional Articles

Get Our Twice Weekly Newsletter!

* indicates required

Rose Law Group pc values “outrageous client service.” We pride ourselves on hyper-responsiveness to our clients’ needs and an extraordinary record of success in achieving our clients’ goals. We know we get results and our list of outstanding clients speaks to the quality of our work.

News Categories

Phoenix metro leads the nation as top homebuyer’s market

By Angela Gonzales | Phoenix Business Journal As the housing market continues to cool, metro Phoenix leads the nation as the country’s top market favoring homebuyers, a new study shows. Local experts had called Phoenix a buyer’s market in October. Home sales platform Knock ranked metro Phoenix at the top of its

Read More »
August 2012