You are here:  Home  >  Courts/Law  >  Current Article

Phoenix defends anti-discrimination law against challenge to high court

Posted by   /  September 10, 2018  /  No Comments

    Print       Email

Breanna Koski and Joanna Duke of Brush and Nib Studio/Alliance Defending Freedom


By Howard Fischer Capitol Media Services via Arizona Daily Star

Phoenix is fighting back against a Christian law firm’s claim to the state’s high court that businesses have a right to refuse providing certain services to gays.

In new legal filings Friday, attorney for the city Eric Fraser said there is no dispute about the heart of the case.

“If a same-sex couple asks Brush & Nib (Studio) for custom wedding products, Brush & Nib will refuse service, regardless of the wording or design the couple wants,” he told the Arizona Supreme Court.

The owners of the firm would make a plain-vanilla wedding invitation listing “Pat and Pat” if it means “Patrick and Patricia” but refuse to make an identical one for “Patrick and Patrick,” he added.

“That’s why this case is about commerce, not speech, art, or religious beliefs,” Fraser wrote. “Under settled law, the government does not infringe the freedom of speech or religion by prohibiting public accommodations from refusing service based on a customer’s race, religion, sexual orientation, etc.”

Put simply, Fraser said, if a business is willing to do wedding invitations, place cards and similar material for heterosexual couples, it cannot refuse to do the same thing for another couple simply because both are the same sex.

What the high court decides has implications beyond the Phoenix anti-discrimination ordinance.


    Print       Email
  • Published: 2 years ago on September 10, 2018
  • Posted by:
  • Last Modified: September 10, 2018 @ 6:33 pm
  • Filed Under: Courts/Law
  • Tagged With:

Leave a Reply

You might also like...

Arizona gyms must get opportunity to show they can safely reopen, judge rules in rebuke of Ducey

Read More →